|
|
|
This review is spoiler free! Skip To The Verdict? »
It’s got to be hard to write a Year One title, especially for a team with as much history as the Teen Titans.
They’ve gone through a lot of rosters and are well known for containing characters with extremely convoluted (and frequently ret-conned) back-stories. They’ve also been headliners for titles directed solely at children (Teen Titans Go!) as well as titles credited for bringing comics into the realm of complex long form storytelling (New Teen Titans).
But I guess that’s the whole point of a “Year One” – to provide a clear starting point for a team or character that otherwise might be intimidating to start reading.
The team assembled to tackle this problem is writer Amy Wolfram (who has experience in the DC Animated universe), Karl Kerschl on pencils, Serge Lapointe on inks, plus Steph Peru and John Rauch handling coloring (and they really should have a cover byline for their work here.)
This book seeks to tell the story of the founding Silver Age team: Robin (Dick Grayson), Wondergirl, Speedy (who gets left off the front cover for some reason), Aqualad, and Kid Flash. For those of you less acquainted with the DC Universe, Speedy is the kid apprentice to Green Arrow. Everyone else is pretty self explanatory.
The general plot here is that, slightly neglected by their adult partners and starved for some friends their own age, the teen superheroes get together in their new clubhouse and foil some minor crimes. Then there’s some more weirdness, as each kid super is confronted by their mentor acting decidedly weird. The plot isn’t particularly engaging though and feels awkward at times. While that makes for a mixed collection in terms of story, the real challenge is to introduce each character and show the Titans come together as a team. It’s a toughy.
The historical origins for these character are a mixed bag already. Robin is straightforward enough (Circus orphan trained by Batman) and the average reader should know him. Speedy and Kid Flash probably came about as a sales influenced response to Robin’s long standing success. But Wondergirl was originally a younger version of Wonderwoman and only accidentally became her kid sister when used in a storyline through an editor’s mistake. And honestly, even I don’t know much about Aqualad’s original creation and characterization. I haven’t gotten to the Aquaman Showcase Presents volumes yet.
Each of these characters has a huge publishing history and almost all of them (not sure about Aqualad again) have stepped into their mentor’s shoes – Dick Grayson has worn the cowl of the Bat, Wally West graduated to full-fledged Flash for an extensive run (see what I did there? Run, hah. I kill myself) and so on.
It’s fair to say that any fans of these characters have a lot of respect for them. Each of them has started as a plucky sidekick and worked their way up (except, perhaps, Aqualad.)
As a Year One title, though, and a fairly kid-safe one, this book seems entirely geared to new readers. It doesn’t have to be a bad thing (Batman: Year One, of course, is an excellent DCU entry point) but a book that’s supposed to get people excited about reading more should have a next point that makes sense. If the characters presented here aren’t the characters in those latter volumes, does that really help keep readers interested?
Robin is closest to the Dick Grayson we know now (and who developed in the New Teen Titans), but seems far from his 60s origin. He’s a lot broodier and shies from the spotlight associated with being a hero, kind of different from the circus brat moving through acrobatic routines in the middle of cases. It’s not too jarring – if this is a reader’s introduction to him, he might feel the same as he’s presented in Dark Victory or Robin: Year One.
The other characters seem to have one trait that is followed through the entire book. It’s not entirely fair to them. Wondergirl is boy crazy (really?) Kid Flash is impatient and obsessed with fame. Aqualad lacks confidence to the point of repeated “wetting himself” jokes. Speedy is a lech and kind of a jerk. Ok, maybe those last two are fair. And kind of funny when you know their “latter” stories. But I was seriously annoyed with Wondergirl’s complete lack of depth. Either Wolfram was trying really hard to allude to the fact that Wondergirl was pretty much accidentally typo’d into the universe (so she’s about a day old here) or this writer never read any New Teen Titans story. I can’t think of much else to explain why she’s some kind of good-natured teenage fem-bot.
The book isn’t all bad. Actually, I enjoyed it at first. There are a lot of moments in here that are quite entertaining. The dialogue isn’t bad and the plot allows for Batman to act like a total jerk, which I always enjoy. There are a few adorable moments for each character and few of the jokes fall entirely flat. I have to admit I particularly enjoyed a scene where Alfred gets his own sudden appearance, and I like when he’s presented as a fully abled member of the Bat-family.
Part of what makes it easy to read, despite the numerous faults, is that the art is so good. Kerschl and his comrades do an exemplary job. It’s cartoony, but still fits in with the mainstream DC style. The Titan’s bound youthfully through the pages, their lanky forms full of expression.
I particularly enjoyed the care taken with the color scheme in each page. From the green blue of Aqualad’s underwater confrontations to the warm sunset during Wondergirl’s date – the mood is immediately conveyed.
I did notice that the backgrounds are not worked with the same kind of coloring and line quality as the figures, but I didn’t mind the technique. It just helped them stand out more.
It’s a shame that the good things couldn’t bring the book together more. The ending is rushed and several plot threads felt unfinished. Speedy just disappears. I don’t really like the “face your fears in a psychic confrontation” style climax, either. It’s a lazy way to directly show what each character is going through.
I guess that I felt let down. Maybe the “Year One” prefix caused me to expect too much.
Verdict:
3 out of 5. Scores higher simply because of the art, the story is equally mixed in quality.
Essential Continuity:
Unfortunately, I have to say no. I’m not even sure if it represents current continuity!
It’s not the worst starting place (you don’t want to jump in the middle of a New Teen Titans arc, believe me) but it might not be the best either.
Read first:
If you’re really interested in the origins of the Silver Age Teen Titans, read Showcase Presents: The Teen Titans Vol. 1 or the Silver Age Teen Titans Archives. They’re probably more fun than this anyway, if a bit dated. If you just want to jump into a modern Teen Titans book, you might be better served by starting with Teen Titans Vol. 1: A Kid’s Game.
Read next:
None of this cast is actually in modern ongoings, so if you want to see what happens to them you have to go for the pre-crisis volumes mentioned above. Then you can read the New Teen Titans, which are luckily very very good (if you’re in the mood for the slightly dated 80s storytelling methods.) Not everyone shows up there, though, and a new cast is built fairly quickly. But the characters introduced during these highly regarded arcs are well represented in modern Teen Titans tales, so it’s worth learning your history!
If you want to skip this volume and jump right into the New Teen Titans, you’ll be forgiven. And rewarded.
way to do a review and not mention the creative team at all. Remind me to not take your opinions too seriously.
[Reply]
I dont see why you are so harsh about that. He talked about the pros and cons of both the writing and art, in my book that’s what I want. I don’t care if there are name drops in the review.
[Reply]
You have an entirely fair point. I made sure to tag all the creators in the book’s database entry and entirely forgot to mention them here (I somehow thought I did and I usually try to, but my rushed posting schedule got the better of me.) Thanks for pointing it out. I’ll make sure to edit this post and do my best to remember on future posts.
As for my opinions – I can only give mine and not those of others (though a few have written for this site, and it’s entirely open to community submissions.) I hope they’re helpful to you, but again, if there is any way you see that would make any part of the site more helpful – I’m always open to criticism!
[Reply]
I would have to agree with TheEnd; I only want to know whether the book is any good or not, if I wanted to know so badly who wrote it I’d click onto the Amazon link. He also does a stand-up job mentioning how good, in his opinion, the art and writing is in the trade. Finally just please have the common decency to leave your criticism as constructive criticism rather than just a rude comment, it only serves to make us “to not take your opinions too seriously”.
[Reply]
Thanks to both of you for the defense – I’m fairly new at this and it’s nice to know that I’m pleasing some.
Of course I’m open to criticism, at least, but it is nice when it’s phrased in a constructive way. At least I’m used to quick jabs from long use of the internet and plenty of years at art school. ;)
[Reply]
Interesting review, Ian. Trouble is, I just received the book in the mail. :) It will be a little bit of a while until I get to it, but I’ll have to let you know if I agree with you. I probably will agree, but I still want to read it for completeness sake.
Question: how do you feel about users reviewing books that you have already reviewed?
[Reply]
Oh, definitely read it. It goes pretty quick, so there’s no reason not to.
And even though my feelings are totally mixed on it, I still want it in my collection (though there aren’t any I DON’T want.)
I think I’m ok with posting second opinions if they’re significantly different. It may be up to you to decide if a comment will suffice.
But there are a lot of books out there that haven’t had much or any attention yet (and the database is only set up to have one “review” link under each book.) sooo – we could figure out a way to ghettorig it, but I’m usually excited to read reviews on books that I haven’t gotten to yet either.
Let me know what you think, though, and if you want to write one!
[Reply]
I am now a bit curious to know what books you don’t want in your collection…
[Reply]
haha, I’m an obsessive archivist, so it really just comes down to what I can afford and have room for. There aren’t many books I’d turn down if given freely (well, I’m giving away some that I don’t have room for, like boring cheesecake ala Grim Fairy Tales)
[Reply]
I dunno when you wrote this, but both Dick and Donna are in monthly ongoings with them both being in Justice League and Dick being in just about every Bat book.
[Reply]
Oh and Roy is in Titans.
Upon further reflection, I think you meant this line-up is not an existing Titans team, so you’re correct.
[Reply]
Yeah, that’s all I meant – there’s no modern place to go for people looking for this configuration of characters making up the titans. It’s been some time since they were all on a team together.
[Reply]
Just letting you know, Aqualad doesn’t go onto being Aquaman. You seemed usure. He finds out his identity, and unlocks his Idyllist magic powers and overcomes his evil emperor uncle as Tempest. Alliance with Aquaman, but not his succesor.
[Reply]
Good to know! :D
[Reply]
I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get setup? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would
cost a pretty penny? I’m not very web savvy so I’m not 100% positive.
Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos
[Reply]
When it comes to hair thinning, you should go with natural organic shampoos over any other product out on the market.
An hour long hair ritual can be cut down to a 5 minute styling with a waterless shampoo.
Unfortunately, it usually takes another three months
before the problem solves itself and by that time you’re already trying everything you
can think of to stop your hair from falling out.
[Reply]
Hi! I could have sworen I’ve visited this web
Ñ•ite before but after going through many of the artticles I realized it’s new to
me. Anyѡаys, І’m certainly happy I stumbled upon it and I’ll be book-marking it aaÕ¸d
checking back ofteÕ¸!
[Reply]
Why viеѡers still use tо read news Ïapers when in this technological É¡lobe the wholle
thing is available on web?
[Reply]
Hey tɦere! Do you knoѡ if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
If you knß‹w of any please share. Kudos!
[Reply]
As soon as you grow rid of the additional padding around the
upper thighs, you need to have sculpted muscles to flaunt.
Unfortunately, spot reduction isn’t feasible, whatever you have read.
The right diet, which raises the core temperature of one’s body will help you
lose leg fat quickly.
[Reply]
If not, then just buy your friends and family their very own
pair. If a comedian starts his setup too early or
finishes it too late, it throws the whole joke off kilter.
Look for words that describe in much greater detail.
[Reply]
It’s going to be ending of mine day, but before ending I am reading this fantastic article to improve my knowledge.
[Reply]
Hi are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own.
Do you need any coding expertise to make your own
blog? Any help would be greatly appreciated!
[Reply]
This paragraph will assist the internet viewers for setting up new
webpage or even a weblog from start to end.
[Reply]
hello!,I really like your writing so a lot!
share we communicate extra about your article on AOL?
I need a specialist in this house to solve my problem.
Maybe that’s you! Taking a look ahead to peer you.
[Reply]
Thanks for sharing such a nice opinion, post is pleasant, thats why i
have read it fully
[Reply]
Wow that was strange. I just wrote an very long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t
appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again.
Anyways, just wanted to say excellent blog!
[Reply]
I think the admin of this web page iss truly working hard in favor of his web page, as here every stuff is quality based
material.
[Reply]
Superb, what a webpage it is! This webpage provides useful information to us, keep it up.
[Reply]