| Includes Issues: | Earth X 0-12, X | |
| Original Publication Dates: | March 1999 - June 2000 | |
| TPB Publisher: | Marvel Comics | |
| TPB Publication Dates: | July 5, 2006 | |
| ISBN-10: | 0785123253 (Softcover)
| |
| ISBN-13: | 978-0785123255 (Softcover)
| |
| Pages: | 472 | [More Info] |
For most books, this information is collected from the book itself and double checked against several other resources. If this particular book hasn't yet been released, the information probably comes from the publisher's press releases and
Amazon.com.
Sometimes a book is listed here based upon a past solicitation, but never actually comes out. I like to keep these in the database, but I try to make a note of the situation.
I try to list the earliest publication date. For books with a hardcover and softcover or multiple editions this will be for whichever came first. Same for the ISBN numbers.
If there have been similar releases that have significant differences, eventually both will be listed. This means that Showcase and Archives that collect similar material are listed as separate books. Likewise, Omnibus, Deluxe, or Absolute editions will have a separate page, though they will probably be close in the timeline.
If you think
any of the information on this page is off, feel free to leave a comment with a suggestion! You may also leave links to relevant information, alternative publications, reviews, or anything you think would be helpful to site visitors.
| Lists: | Comics, Marvel Modern Age, Marvel Universe | |
| Series/Event: | Earth X, What If? | |
| Creators: | Alex Ross, Bill Reinhold, Jim Krueger, John Paul Leon | |
| Characters: | Avengers, Beast, Captain America, Celestials, Deviants, Fantastic Four, Inhumans, Invaders, Iron Man, Skrulls, Spider-Man, X-Men, X-Men Family | |
| Edition: | Softcover | [More Info] |
Each book is tagged and sorted by the terms above. Every link in this section (in orange) can be used to generate a dynamic reading list based on the term.
The
Lists are large reading orders including every book that falls under them. For example, the
DC Universe list includes every book in that shared universe. This taxonomy is
hierarchical, which means that there can be sub-lists under the main lists. The DC Universe
Pre-Crisis list is an example, allowing you to narrow the selection of DC books. The distinction is important, because eventually there will be Silver Age book lists for Marvel
and DC, and the lists will
not be intermingled because of that hierarchy. Look to the list information in the sidebar to see all the lists currently active. Check the header of each listing for specific information about each one.
The
Series/Event taxonomy, like the rest, is not hierarchical. Not every book is part of a particular publication series, nor necessarily included in the reading order for an event. Events often include specific crossovers and tie-ins, but many event reading orders also include books purely because they are recommended for appreciation and understanding of that event.
The
Creators will be tagged in every book in the database. These include all the writers, artists, and editors that worked on the collected material, as well as anyone who significantly contributed to the collected edition.
The
Characters are very important to this database, since most users enjoy seeing a reading list generated by their favorite heroes and villains. Since each book is tagged with any reoccurring character inside, the amount of orders that can be generated through these tags is staggering.
Since there is so much information to be found in each book, it's relatively common for a couple tags to be missed. If you think this book needs attention - should be given any additional tags or moved off a particular list, for example - just leave me a comment and I'll get right back to you!
These links take you to the previous or next book in the database. It's worth a mention that, at this point, this is specifically
in the database.
That means that if you came to this book page via a specific character reading order, for example, the links may point to books that were
not listed on the previous page's reading order. This is because they are taking into account the entire database.
At this time, they go by the
Recommended Reading Order (or equivalents for non-DCU lists) for determining which books to link.
I am currently looking into getting them to give direction based on what page you came from, but it's possible that there is no solution to that issue.
| Unique Reading Order ID: | 198310251200 | |
| Chronological List Value: | 2000.06 | |
| TRO Database Book ID: | 9047 |
[More Info] |
The
Unique Reading Order ID determines this book's placement in all lists generated from the
Recommended Reading Order (or equivalents for non-DCU lists). It's not actually unique site-wide, but is unique for each major list. This value is actually based on a date system, but has no relation to any real dates.
The
Chronological List Value is determined by the most recent publication date of collected contents. This value determines book placement on all lists generated chronologically.
The
TRO Database Book ID is a value indicative of when this book was added. It is used primarily for reference within the TRO database and not for sorting. It used to help with interpage linking, but has been replaced with a more user friendly "slug" (web url title) system.
These values are provided for the purposes of sorting your own collections. You could keep an excel spreadsheet or google document with the titles of the books in your collection. In columns next to the books, place each of these numbers. Then when you display the list sorted numerically by either of these columns, your books will fall into order.
Of course, now that TRO's
built in collection sorting feature is active, it's much easier to sort your books. But these numbers still display just in case you'd like to use them or are curious about the inner operation of the website.
Registered users may edit their comments past the 5 minute limit. [
HTML is allowed, but posts containing more than two links or sketchy code will be held for moderation.
I just saw that this and a bunch of other non-“What If?” books are tagged with “What If?” It’s not really the same as Elseworlds, in that it’s not a blanket term for out-of-continuity books. “What If?” really only refers to the specific series of that name. A better tag for some of these would be “Non-Canon” or something. And books like Earth X might not even need that as long as they all have a series tag.
[Reply]
I wanted to slap em all in once place and that seemed the easiest way to do it. I suppose I can take them out (I’ll keep this comment in my in box to remind me.)
What else would go in a Non-Canon tag?
[Reply]
Most of what’s currently tagged as “What If,” to be honest. Banner, the “The End” books, Peter Porker, 1985, Iron Man: Crash, the movie stuff, etc. Basically, my thought is that if it’s a trade with “What If” in the title, or it contains one or more issues of “What If” in the contents, it should have the tag. Otherwise, “Non-Canon.”
The reasoning, in case I didn’t explain this clearly enough, is that “What If?” a specific thing with its own feel and its own purpose. Stories with the “What If” brand are, traditionally, stories narrated by The Watcher, who usually explains that the story you’re about to read takes place in an alternate universe or whatever. It’s kinda campy, but in a fun, Twilight Zone kinda way. They’ve done that from the very first issue in the ’70s all the way through the most recent issues today.
Something like Earth X, on the other hand, takes itself pretty seriously and doesn’t rely on its non-canon status for rhetorical effect.
Also, Iron Man 2020 shouldn’t be “What If” OR “Non-Canon.” It takes place in an alternate universe, but that alternate version of Iron Man later shows up in the Marvel Universe proper.
[Reply]
haha ok, this is gonna take a little more work than I’m gonna do today. Let’s start a thread about it.
[Reply]
What’s up colleagues, fastidious post and pleasant urging
commented at this place, I am genuinely enjoying by these.
[Reply]